Comparison
Vyse vs. 99designs
TL;DR: 99designs runs spec contests where designers work for free hoping to win. Vyse does discovery, strategy, and custom design with a defined process. The model determines the quality of the thinking — not just the output.
At a glance
| Factor | Vyse | 99designs |
|---|---|---|
| Process | Discovery → strategy → design | Brief → contest → pick a winner |
| Research | ✓ Competitive analysis first | ✗ Designers guess from brief |
| Concepts | 2–3 strategic, with rationale | Dozens of generic submissions |
| Revisions | ✓ Structured rounds, clear scope | ✗ Varies by designer |
| IP ownership | ✓ Full transfer on completion | ✓ Transfers to winner (check T&Cs) |
| File formats | ✓ AI, SVG, PDF, PNG, Figma | ✗ Depends on designer |
| Brand guidelines | ✓ Included in full packages | ✗ Not typically included |
| Starting price | From $800 (Logo Only) | From $299 (contest tier) |
The 99designs model
- —Post brief — designers guess what you need
- —Dozens of spec concepts submitted simultaneously
- —Designers optimize for winning the vote, not your brand
- —No competitive research before design begins
- —No ongoing relationship or brand stewardship
- —Most experienced brand designers avoid spec contests
The Vyse model
- —Discovery call — we learn your business and market
- —Competitive research before any design begins
- —2–3 strategic concepts with full design rationale
- —Structured revision rounds with defined scope
- —Complete brand system: logo, color, type, guidelines
- —All files transferred on final payment
A designer who doesn't know your business, your competitors, or your customers cannot design a brand that positions you against them. The contest model structurally prevents this. In our work building identities for 150+ brands, every brief we write starts with competitive research — because you can't design a differentiator without first knowing what you're differentiating from.
Common questions
Is Vyse better than 99designs?
For businesses that need strategic brand identity — not a spec-work lottery — yes. 99designs runs a contest model where dozens of designers submit generic concepts without knowing your business. Vyse does discovery research first, then builds a brand system specifically for your positioning, market, and competitors.
What is 99designs and how does it work?
99designs is a marketplace where you post a brief and a budget, dozens of designers submit speculative concepts, and you pick a winner. Everyone else worked for free. The model structurally incentivizes fast, template-adjacent work — designers need volume to survive, not depth.
When would 99designs make sense?
For very simple, low-stakes logo needs with a crystal-clear brief and an outcome that doesn't significantly affect your business positioning. For anything that matters to how customers perceive you — a 99designs logo will look like a 99designs logo.
How much does 99designs cost compared to Vyse?
99designs contests run $299–$1,999. Vyse's Logo Only package is $800–$1,800. The price overlap is significant, but the process is completely different: 99designs gives you quantity of concepts, Vyse gives you quality of thinking. In our experience, brands that used 99designs and later came to Vyse consistently spent more in total.
Do professional designers use 99designs?
Most serious brand designers don't do spec work. Working for free on the chance of winning a contest isn't a sustainable business model for experienced professionals. The designers who compete on 99designs are typically earlier in their careers or supplementing income — which is fine for some projects, but means you're trading strategic depth for volume.
Want design built for your brand — not guessed?
Brand identities from $800. Free 30-minute consultation.